Party Supplies Checklist for Private Events

Planned from more than 500 real events

Party Supplies Checklist: Recommended Picks for Private Events

Use this party supplies checklist to choose drinkware, napkins, straws, decor, coolers, tables, and event setup essentials for a polished private party. Every recommendation reflects what Bartend Long Island has seen work across more than 500 events.

Shop by Event Need

Why these recommendations

How We Choose These Recommendations

Bartend Long Island has planned and managed more than 500 private events across Long Island and surrounding areas. These recommendations are selected based on the questions hosts ask most often, the setup challenges we see repeatedly, and the types of products that make private-event service smoother, more polished, and easier to manage. Availability and styles may change, so we periodically review and update the guide.

Update policy: Product availability, designs, pricing, and listing details can change. We periodically review this guide and update recommendations when an item becomes unavailable, no longer fits our standards, or a stronger option becomes available.

Bartend Long Island recommends

Drinkware

Drinkware is one of the most common planning questions we receive. The right answer depends on guest count, event length, drink menu, and how elevated you want the setup to feel.

Planning guidance

A safe estimate is about 1.5 cups per guest per hour, rounded up. This provides room for guests changing drinks, misplaced cups, and fresh glassware during longer events.

  • 25 guests for 3 hours: about 115 cups
  • 50 guests for 3 hours: about 225 cups
  • 75 guests for 3 hours: about 340 cups
  • 100 guests for 3 hours: about 450 cups

You may also want separate wine or champagne cups when those beverages are an important part of the event.

Disposable rocks glass recommended for Old Fashioneds and whiskey cocktails Whiskey Pick

Amazon affiliate link

10 oz Disposable Rocks Cups

The right shape when Old Fashioneds, whiskey drinks, spirit-forward cocktails, or premium pours are an important part of the menu.

Best for: Old Fashioneds, Manhattans over ice, bourbon service, whiskey bars, and premium cocktail menus.

Planning note: Use these selectively when a rocks-glass shape adds value to the presentation.

View on Amazon
Stemless disposable wine cup for private events and outdoor parties

Amazon affiliate link

Stemless Wine Cups

A stable and attractive choice when wine is being poured throughout the event. The stemless design is less likely to tip than a traditional disposable wine glass.

Best for: Wine service, cocktail hour, showers, dinner parties, and outdoor events.

Planning note: Purchase separately when wine drinkers should not need to reuse cocktail cups.

View on Amazon
Stemless disposable champagne flute for wedding toasts and private events Toast Pick

Amazon affiliate link

Stemless Champagne Flutes

Use dedicated champagne drinkware when a toast, welcome pour, mimosa bar, or sparkling cocktail is an intentional part of the event experience.

Best for: Wedding toasts, bridal showers, mimosas, champagne welcomes, and sparkling cocktails.

Planning note: Plan one flute per expected toast or sparkling-wine guest, plus a small buffer.

View on Amazon
Silver rimmed disposable cocktail cup for weddings and private events

Amazon affiliate link

9 oz Silver Rim Cocktail Cups

A polished alternative to gold when the event uses cooler colors, silver accents, white florals, or a modern neutral theme.

Best for: Weddings, anniversaries, corporate events, milestone birthdays, and modern event palettes.

Planning note: Use as the main cocktail cup or pair with separate wine and champagne drinkware.

View on Amazon
Decorative disposable party shot cups for milestone celebrations Party Pick

Amazon affiliate link

Decorative Party Shot Cups

A more playful option for milestone birthdays, themed celebrations, graduation parties, and events where the shot presentation is part of the atmosphere.

Best for: Birthdays, graduations, themed parties, bachelor or bachelorette celebrations, and late-night service.

Planning note: Keep the quantity aligned with the planned serving moment instead of the full event duration.

View on Amazon
Clear disposable shot cup for celebrations and tasting stations

Amazon affiliate link

Clear Disposable Shot Cups

A simple option for controlled celebratory pours, tasting moments, or small-format drinks when shots are intentionally included in the event plan.

Best for: Celebratory shots, tasting stations, mini cocktails, and measured specialty pours.

Planning note: Only buy these when shots or mini drinks are actually part of the planned menu.

View on Amazon
Clear 9 ounce disposable cocktail cup for private event bar service Best Value

Amazon affiliate link

9 oz Clear Cocktail Cups

The most flexible choice for mixed drinks when appearance, simplicity, and budget all matter. Clear cups allow colorful cocktails and garnishes to remain the visual focus.

Best for: Backyard parties, graduations, casual celebrations, and high-volume cocktail service.

Planning note: A dependable base cup for most cocktails served over ice.

View on Amazon
Back to categories

Bartend Long Island recommends

Beverage Napkins

Beverage napkins protect surfaces, support cleaner service, and help the bar look intentionally finished. Choose the style around the event atmosphere, then make sure the quantity is practical.

Planning guidance

Plan for 2 to 3 beverage napkins per guest. Round up for cocktail-style events, outdoor parties, dessert tables, and self-serve drink stations.

  • 25 guests: 50 to 75 napkins
  • 50 guests: 100 to 150 napkins
  • 75 guests: 150 to 225 napkins
  • 100 guests: 200 to 300 napkins

For premium or personalized napkins, use the decorative option where guests will see it and keep plain beverage napkins available as backup.

Grey and white bordered disposable beverage napkins for private events Versatile Pick

Amazon affiliate link

Grey & White Border Beverage Napkins

A clean, understated option that works with white, silver, coastal, and modern neutral event palettes. The border gives the napkin a finished look without competing with the drinks, flowers, or bar sign.

Best for: Bridal showers, daytime parties, coastal events, corporate gatherings, and neutral event styling.

Planning note: Use as the main bar napkin and plan for 2 to 3 per guest.

View on Amazon
Black cocktail beverage napkins with gold decorative lines Evening Pick

Amazon affiliate link

Black & Gold Cocktail Napkins

A bold decorative choice when the bar needs contrast or the event uses black and gold accents. These work best when the napkin is meant to contribute to the theme rather than disappear into the setup.

Best for: Milestone birthdays, retirement parties, evening celebrations, New Year events, and black-and-gold themes.

Planning note: Use as the visible accent napkin and keep plain backups available for high-volume service.

View on Amazon
White linen feel cocktail napkin with a gold foil botanical accent Elevated Pick

Amazon affiliate link

Gold Foil Linen-Feel Napkins

A polished linen-feel option with a restrained gold botanical detail. It adds a premium finishing touch without covering the entire napkin in a busy pattern.

Best for: Wedding cocktail hours, anniversaries, bridal showers, champagne bars, and elegant neutral themes.

Planning note: Use these at the bar or welcome-drink station and support larger events with plain white backups.

View on Amazon
Back to categories

Bartend Long Island recommends

Straws & Stirrers

Choose straws, stirrers, and cocktail picks around the drinks being served. The goal is to support the menu and presentation without placing unnecessary items at every glass.

Planning guidance

Not every drink needs a straw. Mojitos, crushed-ice cocktails, tall lemonades, highballs, and many mocktails usually benefit from one. Old Fashioneds, wine, champagne, and most spirit-forward drinks generally do not.

  • Estimate one straw or stirrer for each drink expected to use one.
  • Add approximately 20 percent for dropped, misplaced, or double-used pieces.
  • Plan one cocktail pick for each drink receiving olives, cherries, citrus, berries, or decorative garnishes.

Short straws work best with rocks cups. Taller straws are better for highballs, mojitos, lemonades, and larger beverage cups.

Colorful tropical umbrella drinking straws in a mint cocktail Tropical Pick

Amazon affiliate link

Tropical Umbrella Drink Straws

A playful straw and decoration combination for events where the drink presentation is meant to feel tropical, colorful, and relaxed. They add an immediate party detail without requiring a separate cocktail umbrella.

Best for: Luau parties, pool parties, tropical cocktails, frozen drinks, beach themes, and summer celebrations.

Planning note: Use selectively for the featured tropical drink instead of placing them in every beverage.

View on Amazon
Bamboo cocktail garnish picks with decorative gold beads Garnish Pick

Amazon affiliate link

Gold Accent Bamboo Cocktail Picks

A useful garnish pick with enough decorative detail to feel elevated. These help secure olives, cherries, berries, citrus pieces, and small fruit garnishes while adding a subtle gold accent.

Best for: Martinies, Old Fashioneds, fruit garnishes, cocktail cherries, olives, and premium signature drinks.

Planning note: Plan one pick per garnished cocktail and include a small backup supply.

View on Amazon
Gold disposable paper cocktail straws in bulk packaging Celebration Pick

Amazon affiliate link

Gold Paper Cocktail Straws

A decorative short straw that works well when gold is already part of the event palette. The compact size is more appropriate for cocktail cups than oversized full-length paper straws.

Best for: Birthdays, showers, anniversary parties, champagne themes, black-and-gold events, and signature cocktails.

Planning note: Use for the featured cocktail or visible bar display and keep a practical backup option available.

View on Amazon
Back to categories

Bartend Long Island recommends

Decorative Elements

Decorative elements should make the bar or beverage area feel more intentional without getting in the way of service. The best pieces either create visual impact, help display drinks and food, or make the station easier for guests to understand.

Planning guidance

Focus on 2 to 4 strong decorative pieces instead of overcrowding the setup. A single statement item, a serving display, a lighting element, and a small sign usually go further than too many competing accents.

  • Choose one main focal piece for the bar, welcome drink table, or self-serve station.
  • Use tiered displays and trays to add height and make the setup feel more styled.
  • Use battery-powered lighting instead of open flames when possible.
  • Keep beverage and food displays visually clean so guests can still move easily through the setup.
  • Match finishes and colors rather than mixing too many styles in one station.

Pieces like drink dispensers and acrylic tubs are included here because they serve a display function in addition to being practical.

Wooden three tier entertaining stand for food and decor display Rustic Pick

Amazon affiliate link

Wooden 3-Tier Entertaining Stand

A warm, rustic-style display piece that adds height and variety to a grazing table, dessert table, or styled beverage station. It works well when the event leans natural, farmhouse, or casually elevated.

Best for: Backyard parties, rustic themes, grazing displays, dessert tables, and outdoor entertaining.

Planning note: One stand works well for a smaller feature station. Use more than one for larger displays.

View on Amazon
Light up BAR sign with marquee style bulbs Party Accent

Amazon affiliate link

Light-Up BAR Sign

A playful accent that helps define the bar area and gives the setup a more finished party look. It works best when the host wants the beverage station to feel like a destination instead of just a utility table.

Best for: Birthdays, home bars, themed parties, backyard events, and photo-friendly bar setups.

Planning note: Use one sign at the main bar, back bar, or drink station.

View on Amazon
Mini chalkboard tabletop menu signs with markers and stands Labeling Pick

Amazon affiliate link

Mini Chalkboard Menu Signs

Small signs go a long way in helping guests understand what is being served. These are useful for labeling signature cocktails, mocktails, dessert stations, or self-serve beverage options.

Best for: Signature cocktail stations, mocktail bars, brunches, self-serve drinks, buffets, and dessert displays.

Planning note: A set is usually enough to label multiple stations or drink options at one event.

View on Amazon
Clear acrylic beverage tub filled with ice and bottles Hosting Upgrade

Amazon affiliate link

Clear Acrylic Beverage Tub

A more attractive alternative to a standard cooler when beer, wine, champagne, or soft drinks are being self-served. The clear acrylic look keeps the station cleaner and more event-appropriate.

Best for: Beer and wine stations, backyard events, showers, self-serve beverages, and patio entertaining.

Planning note: One to two tubs usually handle a focused beverage station, depending on guest count and drink volume.

View on Amazon
Set of clear one gallon drink dispensers with spigots for self serve beverages Self-Serve Pick

Amazon affiliate link

1-Gallon Drink Dispenser Set

A practical display piece for water, lemonade, mocktails, and other self-serve beverages. These help create a more intentional drink station than placing bottles or open pitchers on a table.

Best for: Brunches, baby showers, backyard parties, mocktail stations, lemonades, infused waters, and family gatherings.

Planning note: Use one dispenser for a single featured beverage or multiple units for a full self-serve setup.

View on Amazon
Back to categories

Bartend Long Island recommends

Event Setup Essentials

These are the support pieces that help an event feel more complete, organized, and guest-ready. Some are practical necessities, while others add a more polished setup or rental-style presentation.

Planning guidance

Think of this section as the setup layer of the event. The most helpful purchases are the items that improve presentation, create usable serving space, or make beverage and food stations easier for guests to navigate.

  • Use fitted linens to make standard tables feel cleaner and more intentional.
  • Add one or two extra surfaces for desserts, welcome drinks, or self-serve items.
  • Keep chilling equipment separate from the main bar when guests will be serving themselves.
  • Use larger support pieces only when they solve a real layout need or add a meaningful visual moment.
  • For outdoor events, think through mobility, storage, and how quickly supplies can be restocked.

Many of these are the types of pieces hosts eventually decide to rent, but they are also useful to own if you entertain often.

White fitted tablecloth covers for six foot rectangular tables Setup Upgrade

Amazon affiliate link

Fitted 6-Foot Table Cover

One of the easiest upgrades for making a basic folding table look more polished. A fitted cover works especially well for buffet tables, dessert tables, favor tables, or bar-back support tables that guests will still see.

Best for: Buffets, dessert tables, welcome tables, gift tables, and event setups using standard folding tables.

Planning note: Buy to match the number of guest-facing 6-foot tables you plan to use.

View on Amazon
White folding six foot utility table with collapsible legs Host Essential

Amazon affiliate link

Folding White 6-Foot Utility Table

Not glamorous, but one of the most useful event purchases you can make. Extra table space solves a surprising number of hosting problems, from dessert displays to backstock, gift tables, check-in areas, and buffet support.

Best for: Buffets, dessert setups, prep surfaces, favor tables, backstock, and general event overflow.

Planning note: Even one extra utility table can be valuable. More are helpful for larger self-serve or food-heavy setups.

View on Amazon
Back to categories

Bartend Long Island recommends

Bar Signs & Custom Banners

Clear, coordinated signage helps guests find the bar, understand the cocktail menu, and immediately recognize the style of the celebration.

Planning guidance

Start with the sign guests need most. For the bar, that is usually a readable signature cocktail menu that lists each drink and its main ingredients.

  • Cocktail menu: place it directly at the bar where guests can read it before ordering.
  • Welcome sign: use it near the entrance to establish the event style.
  • Fabric banner: a useful way to personalize a bar front or display table.
  • Easel or stand: confirm the sign dimensions and weight before purchasing.

Keep fonts large, contrast strong, and wording concise. A beautiful sign is only useful when guests can read it quickly.

Personalized arched signature drinks wedding menu sign displayed on an easel Signature Menu

Amazon affiliate link

Personalized Signature Drinks Wedding Menu

A polished arched sign for couples who want the signature cocktails to feel like a designed part of the reception rather than a basic printed list. The arch shape works especially well with modern, neutral, and romantic wedding decor.

Best for: Wedding receptions, engagement parties, rehearsal dinners, and his-and-hers signature cocktail menus.

Planning note: Place it at eye level near the ordering side of the bar and keep the drink descriptions short enough to scan quickly.

View on Amazon
Personalized fabric wedding bar banner displayed on the front of a white bar Barfront Upgrade

Amazon affiliate link

Personalized Fabric Bar Menu Banner

A high-impact way to customize the front of a simple bar or service table. The fabric format adds names, colors, or event wording without requiring a separate floor display.

Best for: Weddings, engagement parties, showers, milestone celebrations, and plain rental bars that need a customized focal point.

Planning note: Measure the visible front of the bar before ordering and make sure the banner can be attached without interfering with service.

View on Amazon
Personalized white wedding welcome sign displayed on a wooden easel Welcome Display

Amazon affiliate link

Personalized Wedding Welcome Sign

A simple entrance sign that helps the event feel intentional from the moment guests arrive. The clean white design can work across a wide range of wedding styles and floral palettes.

Best for: Wedding entrances, engagement parties, rehearsal dinners, showers, and formal event welcome areas.

Planning note: Pair it with a stable easel and position it where guests naturally enter without blocking the walking path.

View on Amazon
Gold adjustable metal easel for wedding and event signs Display Essential

Amazon affiliate link

Gold Adjustable Sign Easel

A more elevated alternative to a basic wooden stand when the event uses gold hardware, warm metallic details, or a modern wedding palette. It keeps menu and welcome signs visible without adding visual bulk.

Best for: Wedding welcome signs, seating charts, cocktail menus, showers, and formal display stations.

Planning note: Confirm the supported sign size and weight, especially for outdoor events where wind can affect a lightweight display.

View on Amazon
Custom illuminated wedding neon name sign displayed against a floral greenery wall Statement Sign

Amazon affiliate link

Custom Wedding Neon Sign

A true statement piece for couples who want their names or event wording to become part of the decor and photography. It works especially well against greenery walls, floral installations, or behind a sweetheart table.

Best for: Wedding receptions, photo backdrops, sweetheart tables, dance floors, engagement parties, and reusable home decor after the event.

Planning note: Plan the mounting surface, power access, cord placement, sign dimensions, and installation method before the event day.

View on Amazon
Back to categories

Prefer to leave it to us?

Want Help Pulling the Bar Setup Together?

You can absolutely handle the supplies yourself, but if you would rather not worry about what to buy, what to prep, or how the bar should be set up, Bartend Long Island can help plan the bar experience around your event.